Menas' Result is Best Possible

Authors:
Arthur W. Apter and Saharon Shelah

Journal:
Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. **349** (1997), 2007-2034

MSC (1991):
Primary 03E55; Secondary 03E35

MathSciNet review:
1370634

Full-text PDF Free Access

Abstract | References | Similar Articles | Additional Information

Abstract: Generalizing some earlier techniques due to the second author, we show that Menas' theorem which states that the least cardinal which is a measurable limit of supercompact or strongly compact cardinals is strongly compact but not supercompact is best possible. Using these same techniques, we also extend and give a new proof of a theorem of Woodin and extend and give a new proof of an unpublished theorem due to the first author.

**[AS]**A. Apter, S. Shelah,*On the Strong Equality between Supercompactness and Strong Compactness*, Transactions AMS**349**(1997), 103-128.**[Ba]**A. R. D. Mathias (ed.),*Surveys in set theory*, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series, vol. 87, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1983. MR**823774****[Bu]***Handbook of mathematical logic*, North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam-New York-Oxford, 1977. Edited by Jon Barwise; With the cooperation of H. J. Keisler, K. Kunen, Y. N. Moschovakis and A. S. Troelstra; Studies in Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics, Vol. 90. MR**0457132****[C]**James Cummings,*A model in which GCH holds at successors but fails at limits*, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc.**329**(1992), no. 1, 1–39. MR**1041044**, 10.1090/S0002-9947-1992-1041044-9**[CW]**J. Cummings, H. Woodin,*Generalised Prikry Forcings*, circulated manuscript of a forthcoming book.**[J]**Thomas Jech,*Set theory*, Academic Press [Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers], New York-London, 1978. Pure and Applied Mathematics. MR**506523****[Ka]**Akihiro Kanamori,*The higher infinite*, Perspectives in Mathematical Logic, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1994. Large cardinals in set theory from their beginnings. MR**1321144****[KaM]**A. Kanamori and M. Magidor,*The evolution of large cardinal axioms in set theory*, Higher set theory (Proc. Conf., Math. Forschungsinst., Oberwolfach, 1977), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 669, Springer, Berlin, 1978, pp. 99–275. MR**520190****[KiM]**Y. Kimchi, M. Magidor,*The Independence between the Concepts of Compactness and Supercompactness*, circulated manuscript.**[L]**Richard Laver,*Making the supercompactness of 𝜅 indestructible under 𝜅-directed closed forcing*, Israel J. Math.**29**(1978), no. 4, 385–388. MR**0472529****[LS]**A. Lévy and R. M. Solovay,*Measurable cardinals and the continuum hypothesis*, Israel J. Math.**5**(1967), 234–248. MR**0224458****[Ma1]**Menachem Magidor,*Changing cofinality of cardinals*, Fund. Math.**99**(1978), no. 1, 61–71. MR**0465868****[Ma2]**M. Magidor,*On the role of supercompact and extendible cardinals in logic*, Israel J. Math.**10**(1971), 147–157. MR**0295904****[Me]**Telis K. Menas,*On strong compactness and supercompactness*, Ann. Math. Logic**7**(1974/75), 327–359. MR**0357121****[MS]**Alan H. Mekler and Saharon Shelah,*When 𝜅-free implies strongly 𝜅-free*, Abelian group theory (Oberwolfach, 1985) Gordon and Breach, New York, 1987, pp. 137–148. MR**1011309****[SRK]**Robert M. Solovay, William N. Reinhardt, and Akihiro Kanamori,*Strong axioms of infinity and elementary embeddings*, Ann. Math. Logic**13**(1978), no. 1, 73–116. MR**482431**, 10.1016/0003-4843(78)90031-1

Retrieve articles in *Transactions of the American Mathematical Society*
with MSC (1991):
03E55,
03E35

Retrieve articles in all journals with MSC (1991): 03E55, 03E35

Additional Information

**Arthur W. Apter**

Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, Baruch College of CUNY, New York, New York 10010

Email:
awabb@cunyvm.cuny.edu

**Saharon Shelah**

Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel;
Department of Mathematics, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey 08904

Email:
shelah@math.huji.ac.il, shelah@math.rutgers.edu

DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-97-01691-7

Received by editor(s):
March 3, 1995

Received by editor(s) in revised form:
December 13, 1995

Additional Notes:
The research of the first author was partially supported by PSC-CUNY Grant 662341 and a salary grant from Tel Aviv University. In addition, the first author wishes to thank the Mathematics Departments of Hebrew University and Tel Aviv University for the hospitality shown him during his sabbatical in Israel.

Publication 496. The second author wishes to thank the Basic Research Fund of the Israeli Academy of Sciences for partially supporting this research.

Article copyright:
© Copyright 1997
American Mathematical Society