Read the latest issue of Notices  Read the latest issue of Bulletin  Shop in the AMS Bookstore  My Account | Cart  
 
American Mathematical Society   

Mathematical Digest


Short Summaries of Articles about Mathematics
in the Popular Press

"A Matter of Choice" by Jim Holt. Lingua Franca, November 2001, page 68.

Holt describes the axiom of choice---its history, consequences, misuse, and standing in modern mathematics. The latter third of the article deals with the Banach-Tarski paradox, which states that using the axiom of choice, one can dissect a solid sphere and without stretching the pieces in any way, reassemble those pieces to form two solid spheres each the same size as the original. A consequence of this is that a solid sphere the size of an orange could be dissected and reassembled into a sphere the size of the sun. Pieces of arbitrarily fine detail are needed, so in practice such reassembly is impossible. Holt relates an amusing tale regarding a bet between Princeton mathematicians and the late physicist Richard Feynman. Feynman challenged the above claim about an orange and the sun saying, "...you said an orange, so I assumed you meant a real orange."

--- Mike Breen

Return to Top