Blog on Math Blogs
Image of the MonthImage of the Month
Image of the Month

"Can warning drivers of traffic jams make congestion worse? Can closing roads make it better? Mathematically yes, but real-world confirmation is hard to find," writes Brian Hayes. Read about "Playing in Traffic."

Related Links Related Links

AMS Members OnlyAMS Members Only

Headlines & Deadlines AMS Members Only

Contact Us

Contact Us

Mike Breen and Annette Emerson
Public Awareness Officers

paoffice at
Tel: 401-455-4000
Fax: 401-331-3842
Tony Phillips Tony Phillips' Take on Math in the Media
A monthly survey of math news
Mail to a friend · Print this article· Previous Columns

This month's topics:

More about John Nash

His life was the subject of full-scale obituaries in Science (June 19, 2015) and in Nature (June 25, 2015). Both focused on his contribution to economics, but each of the authors contributed personal details of his own.

  • In Science, Martin Shubik, a lifelong friend of Nash's, starts back at Princeton in 1949 when he, Lloyd Shapely and Nash shared a suite in the Graduate College. "John, Lloyd, and I were competitive in our research, which John enhanced with practical jokes such as removing the light bulb from a fixture in our joint bathroom and filling it with water, poised to drench his roommates." There is also the account of a game of So Long Sucker (that John had helped invent) played at tea time in Fine Hall, at the end of which John reportedly said to John McCarthy, in essence, "I do not understand why you are mad at me; you could do the backward induction to have seen that it was completely rational for me to double-cross you, and it was not personal."


  • Martin Nowak, who wrote for Nature, did not know Nash nearly as well. The anecdote he contributes, set at the Institute for Advanced Study, may say more about the place and the profession than the man. "One summer's day, when the usual sitting arrangements for lunch were disrupted by the closure of the main kitchen, I noticed John, the physicist Edward Witten and Andrew Wiles, the British mathematician who proved Fermat's last theorem, sitting down together at a small table. I wondered which of them would start the conversation. None of them did. I seem to remember that they ate their meal in silence."



Möbius strips of light

"Observation of optical polarization Möbius strips" appeared in Science, February 27, 2015. The authors, an international team led by Thomas Bauer (Erlangen), report in their Abstract that they construct a q-plate, "a liquid crystal device that modifies the polarization of light in a space-variant manner," tightly focus the emerging beam of light, and then, "using a recently developed method for the three-dimensional nanotomography of optical vector fields, ... fully reconstruct the light polarization structure in the focal region." The reconstruction reveals that this structure contains Möbius strips. As the authors remark: "Despite being easily realized artificially, the spontaneous emergence of [Möbius strips] in nature is exceedingly rare."


Experimentally observed polarization topologies in the focal plane of the beams produced by two different $q$-plates. The image shows how the major axis of the polarization ellipse varies around a circle of 150 nm radius centered on the beam axis. With $q=-1/2$ the axis sweeps out a Möbius strip with three half-twists; with $q=-3/2$ there are five half-twists. Image courtesy of Ebrahim Karimi, Department of Physics, University of Ottawa.

The mathematics of cortical folding

A report in Science for July 3, 2015 has the title: "Cortical folding scales universally with surface area and thickness, not number of neurons." The authors, Bruno Mota and Suzana Herculano-Houzel of UFRJ in Rio de Janeiro, begin: "Larger brains tend to have more folded cortices, but what makes the cortex fold has remained unknown. We show that the degree of cortical folding scales uniformly ... as a function of the product of cortical surface area and the square root of cortical thickness." They add: "This model also explains the scaling of the folding index of crumpled paper balls."


These two sheets, crumpled with the same amount of pressure, started with equal surface area, but the exposed area is larger on the thicker one. Mota and Herculano-Houzel determine that the total area $A_{\rm T}$ and the exposed area $A_{\rm E}$ are related to the thickness $T$ by $ T^{1/2}A_{\rm T} = kA_{\rm E}^{1.1055\pm 0.022}$ "as a single, universal power function across all paper balls of different surface areas and thicknesses."

When the authors examined the problem of cortex folding, i.e. the relation between the total surface area $A_{\rm G}$ of the cortex and its exposed surface area $A_{\rm E}$ they discovered an analogous relation: "$A_{\rm E}$ scales across all lissencephalic [smooth-brained] and gyrencephalic [convoluted-brained] mammals (and even across species usually regarded as outliers such as the manatee and cetaceans [porpoises, whales]) as a single power law of $T^{1/2}A_{\rm G}$." They continue: "The finding that cortical folding scales universally across clades, species, individuals, and parts of the same cortex implies that the single mechanism based on the physics of minimization of effective free energy of a growing surface subject to inhomogeneous bulk stresses applies across cortical development and evolution. This is in stark contrast to previous conclusions that different mechanisms regulated folding at different levels."

Lives of mathematicians, reviewed in Nature

Amir Alexander reviewed two personal views of a mathematician's life for Nature, March 5, 2015. The mathematicians are Cédric Villani (Birth of a Theorem, A Mathematical Adventure, Bodley Head/ Faber and Faber, 2015) and Michael Harris (Mathematics Without Apologies: Portrait of a Problematic Vocation, Princeton Univ. Press, 2015). Alexander characterizes Villani's book as "the personal record of a single-minded quest." This was Villani's search for a full mathematical account of Landau damping, which ultimately led him to the Fields Medal in 2010. Harris' book, by contrast, is "a kaleidoscope of philosophical, sociological, historical and literary perspectives on what mathematicians do, and why. Do they pursue their work for the public good?"--a pose. "Is it the absolute truth of mathematical demonstrations that drives the field?"--a conceit of philosophers. "What about the lauded beauty of mathematics?"--"Perhaps, Harris concedes, but when mathematicians talk about beauty, what they mean is pleasure."

"Perhaps more than any other field, mathematics pulls the practitioner away from the 'normal' world of things and people into a strange alternate universe, in which we catch glimpses of beauty and coherence, but spend most of our time groping in the dark. ... Villani offers one way of straddling that divide; ... Harris presents a very different one. Together, they provide an unmatched perspective on life in this 'problematic vocation' by two of its leading practitioners."

Tony Phillips
Stony Brook University
tony at

Math Digest Math Digest
On Media Coverage of Math

Math Digest includes posts throughout each month, with summaries of math stories and unique insights (and occasionally videos, interviews and podcasts) on math-related topics recently covered by the media.

Recently posted:

On using math to analyze leads in sports, by Allyn Jackson

Want to know what size lead a basketball team needs in order to have a 90 percent chance of winning in the remaining seconds of the game? Just take the square root of the number of remaining seconds and multiply by 0.4602. That's the conclusion of work by Aaron Clauset, a computer scientist at the University of Colorado at Boulder, and his collaborators Marina Kogan and Sidney Redner. After analyzing a huge amount of data from basketball, football, and hockey games, they formulated "a simple model in which the score difference randomly moves up or down over time," the New Scientist says. The model is surprisingly accurate, considering that it incorporates no features of the games. It works well for games like basketball, where the scores are fairly large numbers, but is not very reliable for games like soccer, where scores are small. "[S]o you probably shouldn't use it when betting on the English Premier League," the magazine says.

See "Winning formula reveals if your team is too far ahead to lose," by Gilead Amit. New Scientist, 11 July 2015.

--- Allyn Jackson

Also now on Math Digest: Eugenia Cheng on not being a female role model, a museum's math error that really wasn't, and beating traffic ...

More . .

Read more of Math Digest

Reviews Reviews
Books, plays and films about mathematics

Citations for reviews of books, plays, movies and television shows that are related to mathematics (but are not aimed solely at the professional mathematician). The alphabetical list includes links to the sources of reviews posted online, and covers reviews published in magazines, science journals and newspapers since 1996.

More . .

Read more Reviews

Comments: Email Webmaster

© Copyright , American Mathematical Society
Contact Us · Sitemap · Privacy Statement

Connect with us Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Instagram RSS feeds Blogs YouTube Podcasts Wikipedia