Skip to Main Content

Manjul Bhargava Gives Arnold Ross Lecture

"We enjoyed our day at the museum. The lecture provoked an interesting discussion on the bus ride home about the parallel development of mathematics in different cultures. Thanks to the AMS for providing this opportunity."

"We had a great day - wish you came to Chicago every year!"

West entrance at the Museum of Science and Industry


Approximately 300 high school students from the Chicago area attended the Arnold Ross Lecture by Manjul Bhargava (Princeton University) and the game Who Wants to Be a Mathematician at the Museum of Science and Industry on October 24.

Poetry, Drumming and Mathematics by Manjul Bhargava

Bhargava was introduced by Glenn Stevens (Boston University), chair of the Arnold Ross Lecture Series Committee, and Paul Sally, Jr. (University of Chicago). Sally, who has been instrumental in the establishment and continuance of the Arnold Ross Lectures, gave some background about Arnold Ross (see the Notices for an August 2001 interview) and the lectures. Stevens, himself a product of the Arnold Ross program, pointed out that this lecture was the 17th and told a short story about Bhargava. One day in the 1990s, Stevens' secretary took a call from a student interested in BU's PROMYS program for young scholars. The secretary told Stevens that they just had to save a spot in the program for this student because he was so nice. The student was Bhargava and, as the Chicago audience could see, he is still nice.

Bhargava began his talk by saying that to mathematicians, mathematics is more of an art than a science, and he wished that more students would come to mathematics through art. To show that mathematics is connected to art, Bhargava explained how math relates to the rhythms of playing the tabla (pictured below) and to Sanskrit poetry.

Manjul during his talk


Long and short syllables in Sanskrit poetry have two beats and one beat, respectively. A natural question is: How many rhythms of long and short syllables are possible in, say, an eight-beat line? That is, how many ways are there to arrange the numbers 1 and 2 so that the sum is 8? Bhargava showed the general solution, which is given by what is now called the Fibonacci sequence, obtained by the Sanskrit linguist Hemachandra in the 11th century. After giving an elegant proof of the solution, Bhargava demonstrated various rhythms on his tabla, to the delight of the audience.

Manjul at the tabla


Another question is: How many rhythms are possible using k short syllables and n-k long syllables? A Sanskrit poet solved this problem in 500 B.C., using what he called a "mountain of jewels." This mountain is what is often called Pascal's triangle, but it was discovered long before Pascal's time. The solution to this problem is the combination of n things taken k at a time, or "n choose k." Bhargava also gave an elegant proof of this result, then showed that a "shallow diagonal" in the mountain/triangle connects the two problems, because the sum along that type of diagonal is a Fibonacci number. He also extended the problem to poetry with three types of syllables, which gives a three-dimensional mountain of jewels.

He concluded the talk with a demonstration of more rhythms on his tabla and showed how the rhythms' names are connected with error-correcting codes.

As much as anyone likes free food, it seemed as if the audience could have foregone the subsequent snack break and listened to Bhargava for the whole day. After the break, it was time for Who Wants to Be a Mathematician.

Cory, Rose, Kristine, Matt, Stacy, Jason, Manjul, Winston, Daniel, and Mike

Who Wants to Be a Mathematician

The contestants who played Who Wants to Be a Mathematician are:

Game 1:

  • Matt Byrd, Evanston Township High School
  • Kristine Lee, Glenbrook North High School
  • Cory Smith, Walter Payton College Preparatory High School
  • Anastasiya (Stacy) Vinokur, Niles West High School

Matt, Kristine, Cory, and Stacy

Game 2:

  • Jason Beckman, Lyons Township High School
  • Daniel Lee, Glenbrook North High School
  • Rose Lenehan, Walter Payton College Preparatory High School
  • Winston Luo, Glenbrook South High School

Jason, Daniel, Rose, and Winston

In game one, Kristine and Cory were tied for the first four questions. Kristine then moved into first for a time, before Cory overtook her and won the game. Winning the game earned Cory a place in the bonus round, but he had to wait for game two to be played before having a chance at the $2000 bonus question.

Winston Luo won game two, while Jason and Daniel tied for second (Daniel later won a tie-breaker).

Cory, Winston, with their prizes, and Mike

Winston and Cory then attempted the bonus "Two-Grand Prize" question. It was about properties of a binary opearation. After three minutes of concentration and calculations, both offered their explanations of their chosen response and the audience was polled for its choice. During Winston's very good explanation, he seemed to talk himself into a different choice, which turned out to be Cory's choice as well. With the stage set, the correct choice - Cory's - was revealed. Thus, he won the $2000.

Cory is congratulated by Mike

The prizes won by all contestants follow.

  • $2000 from the AMS and a TI-89 Titanium graphing calculator from Texas Instruments: Cory Smith
  • TI-89 Titanium graphing calculator from Texas Instruments: Winston Luo
  • Maple 10 from Maplesoft: Kristine Lee and Daniel Lee (no relation)
  • Calculus by Anton, Bivens and Davis from John Wiley and Sons: Matt Byrd and Jason Beckman
  • What's Happening in the Mathematical Sciences by Barry Cipra from the AMS: Stacy Vinokur and Rose Lenehan

Jason's Lyons Township classmates

The audience enjoyed the game and enjoyed rooting for the contestants, and was especially captivated by the wonderful Arnold Ross Lecture given by Manjul Bhargava. The AMS thanks the Arnold Ross Lecture Series Committee for its arrangements, and thanks Manjul Bhargava and the contestants for providing such an enjoyable morning. The AMS also thanks the teachers from the participating schools for their role in the event, and extends its gratitude to Texas Instruments, Maplesoft, and John Wiley and Sons for supporting Who Wants to Be a Mathematician.

The Arnold Ross Lectures are annual lectures sponsored by the AMS and held at science museums across the country. Read about the 2005 lecture by Ken Ribet in New York.

Photographs by Who Wants to Be a Mathematician judge and co-creator Bill Butterworth of the DePaul University Department of Mathematical Sciences, and by AMS Public Awareness Officer and game co-creator and emcee Mike Breen.

Find out more about Who Wants to be aMathematician.